All videos › English › Grade 12
Applying Critical Lenses to a Short Text A critical lens is a set of questions, not a replacement for reading. Apply formalist, historical and feminist lenses to one short passage and build a theme.
Sign in to save your place
English · Grade 12 · World and British literature · 3.5 minutes · UK English
Transcript 0:02 Literary theory can sound like a replacement for reading,0:06 a set of labels you stick on a story.0:09 It is the opposite. You already know how to find a0:13 theme and support it with evidence. Today you will learn one0:17 new idea. A critical lens is a set of questions you0:21 bring to a text. Each lens makes you read more closely,0:24 and each one can lead you to a different theme.0:28 Here are three lenses and the main question each one asks.0:33 A formalist lens looks at the text itself.0:36 How do its images, structure and word choices create meaning?0:41 A historical lens looks at the time a text was written0:45 or is set. What customs and events shape it?0:48 A feminist lens looks at gender and power.0:51 Who holds power, who does the work,0:54 and who is heard? There are many other lenses,0:58 but every one of them still needs evidence from the words.1:03 Here is a short original passage. Every evening,1:06 Mira closed her father's shop. She counted the coins twice,1:10 swept the step and turned the sign.1:13 Her brother, who never swept, would inherit the keys.1:16 Mira locked the door and hung her own key on a1:20 string around her neck. Read it once for the story.1:23 Then read it again for details that a lens might pick1:27 up, such as the careful work, the brother who never swept,1:31 and the key.1:32 Now apply each lens. Through a formalist lens,1:35 the short, steady sentences copy Mira's routine,1:39 and the image of keys returns at the end,1:42 where she keeps her own key close.1:44 Through a historical lens, you would ask when and where shops1:48 passed to sons by custom, and how that custom shapes the1:52 ending. Through a feminist lens, you notice that the daughter does1:57 the work while the son inherits. Put the readings together and2:01 a theme appears. Work can earn a claim that custom denies.2:05 Your turn. Which question comes from a formalist lens?2:10 Is it, what inheritance laws applied when the story is set?2:14 Is it, how does the repeated word swept link the siblings?2:18 Or is it, who does the work here,2:21 and who gets the reward? Pause the video and decide.2:25 Then watch for the answer.2:34 The answer is the second one. It asks how a repeated2:38 word inside the text builds meaning, which is the formalist question.2:43 The first choice asks about the laws of a time,2:46 so it belongs to a historical lens.2:49 The third asks who works and who is rewarded,2:52 so it belongs to a feminist lens.2:54 A common mistake is to name a lens and then stop2:58 reading. Another is to force a lens onto a text that3:01 gives it no evidence.3:03 Here is one tip to keep. Choose a lens,3:06 ask its question, then answer with words from the text.3:10 If you cannot quote a word that supports your answer,3:14 try a different lens.3:16 Let us recap. A critical lens is a set of questions,3:20 not a replacement for reading. A formalist lens asks how the3:25 text is built, a historical lens asks what shaped it,3:30 and a feminist lens asks who holds power.3:33 Each one sends you back to the words,3:36 and together they can reveal a theme.3:39 Thank you for learning with Worked Example School.Spotted a mistake? Tell us at contact@workedexampleschool.com .